What To Do with Your Email List: How to Engage, Nurture, and Foster Real Connections

We recently wrote on the basics of building a robust email list.

But once you have a great list, what do you do with it?

Email marketing might seem straightforward, but it requires a smart plan to make sure your messages not only land in inboxes but also spark interest from your subscribers. Considering the sea of emails that flood our inboxes daily, standing out is vital. Especially when it comes to B2B marketing.

This guide is here to give you handy tips and insights into both the basic and advanced parts of email marketing. We’ll chat about the essentials like newsletters and welcome email series, as well as dive into automated email campaigns.

Plus, we’ll share 10 key tips, covering everything from making emails personal and sending them at just the right time, to splitting your audience into groups (that’s called segmentation!) and writing fun, creative copy. Let’s dig in and discover ways to boost your email marketing, keeping your subscribers interested and turning those messages into actions!

The Basics of Effective Email Marketing

Understanding Email Marketing

In the simplest terms, email marketing is using emails to connect with your customers or clients. It’s a direct line to their inboxes, where you can promote your products, share news, or simply keep in touch. It’s not just about selling but also about building and maintaining relationships. Email marketing provides:

  • Direct Communication: Emails allow you to talk straight to customers.
  • Cost-Effective: Compared to other marketing forms, emailing can be quite budget-friendly.
  • Measurable: With the right tools, you can track opens, clicks, and other interactions.

Building an Email List

A solid email list is the backbone of email marketing. This isn’t just any list of email addresses, but a curated list of individuals who have opted in to receive communications from you. Here are a few simple strategies we covered in our recent guide.

  • Value Exchange: Offer something valuable in exchange for their email, like a discount or a downloadable guide.
  • Sign-Up Forms: Place easy-to-use sign-up forms on your website where visitors can see them.
  • Quality Over Quantity: Aim for subscribers who are genuinely interested in your offerings.



email signup form

A great example of an email signup form for a business newsletter.

Compliance and Ethics

Legal compliance and ethical practices are non-negotiable in email marketing. Ensure all your practices comply with laws and respect subscriber preferences.

  • Permission: Only send emails to individuals who have explicitly opted in.
  • Transparency: Be clear about why you’re collecting email addresses and how you’ll use them.
  • Unsubscribe Option: Always include a clear and straightforward way for recipients to opt out.
  • Data Protection: Ensure any data you collect is stored and used securely and complies with data protection laws like GDPR or the CAN-SPAM Act.

3 Core Strategies for Email Marketing


The purpose of newsletters in email marketing often transcends mere product updates or sales pitches. Think of newsletters as a regular check-in with your subscribers that delivers valuable and relevant content directly to their inboxes. It is crucial to strike a balance in content, ensuring it’s not overtly promotional but provides tangible value or insights, thereby nurturing a sustained relationship with the reader.

email newsletters

3 Great examples of email newsletters (HTMLemail)

Consistency is key in sending newsletters; whether weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly, establishing a reliable schedule builds anticipation and forms a habitual engagement with your audience. The inclusion of varied content, such as industry insights, company news, and actionable tips, can keep your newsletters diverse and engaging.

Welcome Journeys

Welcome emails are your first handshake with a new subscriber, and they lay the foundation for the relationship ahead. An impactful welcome email sequence doesn’t just stop at saying “hello”. It guides new subscribers through a thoughtfully carved journey, introducing them to your brand ethos, showcasing your offerings, and possibly nudging them towards their first purchase or interaction.

Crafting an impactful welcome email often entails expressing gratitude for their subscription, providing an overview of what to expect in future communications, and potentially offering a warm welcome in the form of a discount or exclusive content.

Automated Email Sequences

Automated email sequences act as your silent, yet powerful, marketing agents, operating in the background to deliver timely and relevant emails to your subscribers based on specific triggers or behaviors. The essence of effective automated emails lies in their ability to provide the right message at the right time without manual intervention. For instance, cart abandonment emails gently remind customers of items left behind, while re-engagement emails can kindle the interest of subscribers who have fallen dormant.


Implementing successful automated email sequences requires a seamless blend of data analysis and creativity, ensuring each message is both personalized and contextually relevant to the recipient’s journey.

10 Practical Tips for Getting Email Marketing Right

Navigating through the nuanced universe of email marketing demands more than just sending messages to a list. The implementation of thoughtful and strategic practices is essential to make sure your emails get opened and read.

  1. Personalization: Craft emails that speak directly to the user by utilizing data-driven insights to tailor content, offers, and messages that align with their preferences and past behaviors, thereby fostering a sense of individual attention and care.
  2. Timeliness: Identify and harness optimal sending times by analyzing user data to ensure that your emails are delivered when they are most likely to be opened and engaged with, maximizing impact and conversion potential.
  3. Segmentation: Divide your email list into specific segments based on various criteria, such as purchase history or engagement level, to deliver highly relevant and targeted content, enhancing user experience and relationship-building.
  4. Creative Copy: Engage your audience with compelling, concise, and creatively crafted copy that not only reflects your brand’s voice but also captivates the reader’s attention and encourages them to take action.
  5. Mobile Optimization: Ensure your emails are mobile-friendly, providing a seamless viewing experience across all devices, as a significant portion of users access their emails via mobile.
  6. Clear CTA (Call to Action): Implement clear and concise calls to action that guide subscribers effortlessly towards taking the desired action, whether it’s making a purchase, signing up, or reading more.
  7. Testing and Optimization: Employ A/B testing for various email elements such as subject lines, content, and send times to continually refine your strategy based on data-driven insights and maximize efficacy.
  8. Valuable Content: Offer content that provides tangible value to your subscribers, whether through informative articles, exclusive deals, or insightful industry news, fostering a mutually beneficial relationship.
  9. Visual Appeal: Utilize visually pleasing designs and aesthetic coherence in your emails to create an engaging user experience and to convey your brand’s identity effectively.
  10. Compliance and Security: Ensure that your email marketing practices adhere to legal regulations and prioritize the security and privacy of user data, building trust and credibility among your subscribers.

Enhance Email Marketing Strategies with Analytics

Mastering the art of email marketing isn’t solely about crafting compelling content and stunning visuals; it also hinges significantly on data-driven strategies and insights gleaned from analytics. In the dynamic landscape of email marketing, understanding and adapting to your audience’s behaviors, preferences, and engagement patterns is crucial. Analytics allow you to peer into the intricacies of how your emails are received and interacted with.

Engagement metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates offer a window into the efficacy of your campaigns. These metrics can illuminate what’s resonating with your audience and what may need recalibration. For instance, low open rates might prompt a reevaluation of your subject lines or send times, while subpar click-through rates may indicate a need to revisit your content or CTA strategies.

Bounce rates and unsubscribe rates are equally pivotal, providing insights into the health of your email list and the relevance of your content to your audience. A spike in either metric may warrant an audit of your email list quality or a reassessment of the alignment between your content and your audience’s expectations.

email analytics

Email analytics dashboard (emailanalytics.com)

Leveraging analytics goes beyond merely observing metrics. It encompasses utilizing these insights to iteratively refine your strategies, ensuring your emails are perpetually optimized and aligned with your audience’s evolving preferences and needs. By embracing a culture of continuous improvement informed by data, you pave the way for sustainable and impactful email marketing that not only reaches but deeply engages your audience.

Master Engaging Your List to Land New Leads and Sales

Effective email marketing seamlessly melds compelling content, strategic delivery, and data-driven decision-making. By understanding your audience, personalizing content, and continuously refining your strategy through analytics, you cultivate relationships and foster loyalty, steering your brand towards sustainable growth and fortified customer engagement in an increasingly digital world.

Guaranteed to make you look smarter.
(Cuz you will be.)

Start every week with all the digital marketing stories, data, teardowns, case studies, and weird news you need to drop in your next marketing standup meeting.

No ads. No sponsorships. No crap. Unless it’s hilarious crap. We love that.